Archive for September, 2008

Homeowner Moral Hazard

2 comments Written on September 29th, 2008 by
Categories: Crisis2008
If you were a homeowner who was "underwater" - your outstanding principal on your loan was greater than the assessed value of the house - how would you react if you knew that:
  • The government was going to purchase mortgages
  • The government wants to prevent foreclosure and favours modification of principal/interest rather than foreclosing.
The answer, I think, is: you'd stop paying your mortgage payments, just for the heck of it. If the government has purchased your loan - you know they will do anything to stop foreclosing on you, so you'll end up being better off by either a reduced principal, reduced interest rate or both.

And if a bank still owns it, the bank could easily sell your mortgage to the government as it is a "distressed" asset; and then the government will do stuff like reduce your principal/interest.

No matter how you look at it - it's best for even prime borrowers to default on their loan payments, to take things to the breaking point. That is the kind of moral hazard associated with the bill that failed.

I think if you took out just that one clause - basically, no modifications to mortgage principal or interest will be done - I think the bill will be a better one. A moral hazard introduced at the homeowner level will cause absolute financial chaos.

It's probably moot, because the bill failed. And perhaps that's a good thing because it gives people time to think some more and make changes that aren't purely politically motivated. There are problems with other clauses as well, but the mortgage mod is by far the worst one - and I think that removes most means of really making any profit on the deal.

It's not time to panic. It's time to sit and think about what has just happened. It is not a big deal. It is not worthy enough for an 8% drop on the S&P.

If the Indian markets panic tomorrow I will be seriously considering some purchases.

Bailout Plan Rejected, Dow Down the Toilet

4 comments Written on September 29th, 2008 by
Categories: Crisis2008
From Yahoo:
Fear swept across the financial markets Monday, sending the Dow Jones industrials down as much as 705 points, as the financial bailout package was defeated by the House.
This is just nuts. Supposedly they're trying a second time...

Random prediction: Mumbai Real Estate will fall 50%

29 comments Written on September 29th, 2008 by
Categories: RealEstate
So all the realty folks are saying that of all places, Mumbai will see the least impact on real estate prices. Meaning, even if prices drop, Mumbai won't drop by much, or won't drop at all.

Not surprisingly, these statements are made by those whose income is related to how well the realty market behaves, and more importantly, on prices staying up and people greedily lapping up overpriced properties.

So I've decided to be the random predictor of the day, and say that in my not-so-humble opinion, real estate prices in Mumbai will drop 50% from the rates today by 2011.

I know I am likely to be both right and wrong, because we will see some sales at fire-sale prices, but when you look around, you will be quoted a price that seems to be from outer space. (which is pretty expensive, by the way) But I'm just ticked off that anyone can suggest that just because this is Mumbai it cannot see land prices decline. I think price declines will be the biggest in Mumbai of all the metros, including Bangalore. It will take time though, for the panic to set in.

I love three year predictions, don't you?

Lehman’s bonds unbonded from the "guarantee"

No Comments » Written on September 29th, 2008 by
Categories: Crisis2008
Lehman's "capital guaranteed" structured notes are likely to yield only pennies on the dollar:
A brochure pitching $1.84 million of notes sold by Lehman Brothers Holdings Inc. in August, a month before the firm filed for bankruptcy, promised "100 percent principal protection."

...

Some of Lehman's structured notes traded last week in the secondary market, mtn-i said in a Sept. 23 report. "Dealers quoted a trading range between 10 cents and 55 cents on the dollar" for the notes, according to the report.

If you can't trust the word "guarantee" anymore, what can you trust?

Citi Buys Wachovia

No Comments » Written on September 29th, 2008 by
Categories: Crisis2008
Well, at least the banking operations.
Citigroup will absorb up to $42 billion of losses in the deal, with the FDIC covering any remaining losses, the government agency said Monday. Citigroup also will grant the FDIC $12 billion in preferred stock and warrants.
Depositors DO NOT LOSE ANYTHING. Deposits are safe - guaranteed by Citi and then FDIC.

Citi taking a $42 billion loss (if it happens) - this is huge. It's too big to fail of course, but even with the bailout its capital will need serious replenishing. This is not a lot of fun to watch, but from a trader's point of view it is good.

Bailout plan: some details are out

4 comments Written on September 28th, 2008 by
Categories: Crisis2008
Pelosi's draft of the changes to the US bailout plan are in (thanks to Calculated Risk):
  • $700 billion in two installments, congress can say no if they don't like what happened to the first one.
  • Ownership stake in companies that participate. Looks like preferred but even senior to the senior most debt. (first call on assets)
  • No golden parachutes, limits on CEO comp
  • Huge oversight by Congress, includes putting transaction details online
  • Right to modify owned mortgages (this can severely reduce value and "profitability")
Not much clarity in terms of specifics but these are fluid times and lots of things can happen before a plan is finally agreed upon. There is lot of voter opposition to any kind of plan - because simply put, there is no more trust. Everyone's an asshole, especially those in these banks, and this kind of bailout is likely to produce even more hatred once the recession takes control of the general economy. I do not envy the winner of this election.

Note: A lot of people are saying "it's not a bailout, it's an asset purchase". I respectfully disagree. (Which is the formal way of saying, "Puhleeze.") There is a rescue being mooted, the target of the rescue being current banks. If it was an asset purchase plan, the US could have created a taxpayer owned entity called Mortage Mae or Maggie Mae or whatever, and let it buy everything, funded by T-Bills. And then could have taken it public, sold all of its shares at a hefty price and paid back the t-bills when it made a profit. But that doesn't help the current banks, no? So it's a bailout.

Realty pressure: Rents, Sales and Diwali Prayers

1 Comment » Written on September 27th, 2008 by
Categories: RealEstate
BS: Store rentals suffer 20% fall in 4 months
We have seen rentals cooling off by 10 to 20 per cent in the last three to four months,’’ said Ashok Bhasin, managing director, Wadhawan Food Retail, which runs the Spinach brand of convenience stores.

According to property consultants, Kishore Biyani’s Future Group has been unable to strike deals for nearly 6 to 7 lakh sq ft of ready retail space in the last three to four months due to high rentals.

...

“Now retailers are demanding zero rentals and a full revenue-sharing agreement. Until and unless developers realise the need for reasonable rentals, many deals may break off,” said Bappaditya Basu of property consultancy Jones Lang LaSalle Meghraj.

Uhem. Spinach has an outlet close to where I live (and btw, their biggest problem can't be rent. It takes a gazillion hours to check out.) And Biyani just did a big number at Raghuleela mall and called it Vashi Central. I like the revenue-share funda. Now, just get people to actually buy something.

ET: Lehman's failure hurts Indian realty:

[Lehman's bankruptcy] may impact the financial major’s existing investments worth $500 million in realty firms, including DLF and Unitech, besides drying up another $500-million worth of potential investment which was expected to flow into Unitech’s Mumbai projects.
From falling rates, to falling investors. Not a pleasant time to be a realtor.

ET: Dire straits:

ccording to industry sources, the average drop in sales for the industry in the last calendar year was more than 60%. Since April, there has been another drop of 30-40% in sales compared with those last year.

What’s more, the drop has not just been in the bigger metros, but in tier-II and tier-III cities as well. They have seen an average fall of more than 25% between February and August, according to the data compiled by the Associated Chambers of Commerce and Industry of India.

The home buying season typically starts during the festival season (Diwali) and ends in March and most developers do almost 60% of their business in this period. Says S K Sayal, CEO, Alpha G Corp: “We just hope Diwali brings us some relief as we have suffered enough in the last four months. If things do not improve we will be seeing lot of distress sales and massive price cuts.”

So not just commercial but retail as well. Whoa. This gets interesting. The house you wanted to buy may be available for a song .... after 2010. Let the panic set in - it usually takes a couple years.

People who own houses - your first house can never be an asset as long as you live in it, so the price shouldn't matter. We don't really have HELOCs and all that in India at the mo.

China says ok to short selling

1 Comment » Written on September 27th, 2008 by
Categories: Crisis2008
From Bloomberg: China allows short selling:
China's cabinet agreed to let investors buy shares on credit and sell borrowed stock to help develop Asia's second-largest market after prices and trading volumes slumped, an official familiar with the plan said.

....

China's action contrasts with regulators in the U.S., Europe and Australia that have banned short selling in the past week to shore up financial shares battered by the global credit squeeze. China's government is betting the changes will boost trading without spurring further declines after state share buybacks helped the CSI 300 Index rebound from a two-year low.

This is why this might actually end up being China's century. It's time to lead, not follow.