Gilts

First Government Bond Auction Fails

4 comments Written on April 11th, 2010 by
Categories: Bonds, Gilts

On friday, the new financial year’s first government bond auction for 12,000 crores failed; about 448 crores devolved on primary dealers. (101: Auctions are underwritten. So if there’s not enough demand, the dealers, who get a commission on the bond sales in the auction, are supposed to buy what’s left)

That might not be much but here’s the thing – what devolved was the ultra liquid 10 year bond, of which 5,000 crores were supposed to be sold. The two year and 17 year bonds, of 5,000 and 2,000 cr. each, sold completely. The 10-year had a cutoff yield of 7.96%, which does seem pretty high considering they closed Thursday at 7.75% – and yet, not enough demand.

In the market yields went up to 8%. Is it too much supply, inflation fears (interest rates will go up, why buy now) or simply a wait-and-watch approach (so much being issued, lets hang on for a while).

At 8% the yields are already very good compared to insurance annuities and have next-to-zero risk. Financial Express says the FII investments in government securities are close or already at the $5bn limit. They can’t buy more than $200m apiece anyway. We’re in the funny situation of domestic investors shunning government bonds while foreign investors are desperate, but can’t invest because of limits. We really need to open this up to FIIs to a much higher extent – I’d say $100 bn for starters.

Next week’s 13,000 crores. Let’s see how that goes.

Govt. to borrow 287,000 cr. in next 6 months

2 comments Written on March 30th, 2010 by
Categories: Bonds, Gilts

RBI has put the borrowing calendar of GSecs for April-September 2010. The total borrowing is slated to be 287,000 cr. with 11,000 to 15,000 crores borrowed every single week. The current 10 year yield is about 7.74% and with the kind of supply coming up, will it cross 8% again? (It briefly crossed 8% and then went back down)

Note for people who want long term income at 8.5% to 9% buying a longer term government bond direct from the government is probably a great option, better than buying an annuity from any insurance company. (More: Low Annuity Returns in India)

RBI has also noted they’ll be selling treasury bills – securities which are between three months to a year in maturity – of 109,000 cr. The interest on this is obviously lower (order of 4%) and is usually bought by banks and FIs. There’s nothing unusual about this – standard short term operations.

Government Debt: A Visual Analysis

2 comments Written on March 23rd, 2010 by
Categories: Debt, Gilts, InterestRates

Our government is going to issue a truckload of bonds next year, so let’s see where we are right now with respect to current bonds outstanding.

Total Bonds Issued: 18,26,501 cr. (18.26 trillion, excludes MSS of 2000 cr.)
Total Interest we will pay next year: 146,610 cr.
Total Taxes Collected (Estimate): 746,651 cr.
Interest paid as a % of taxes: 19.64%.

This is quite high – and the taxes mentioned are gross amounts – net of state sharing, and including certain non tax revenue items like dividend and interest received, the real revenue of the government is just 682,212 cr. – interest being paid out is 21.5% of that!

Let’s then look at how much is maturing in which year:

image

Source: Finmin

Around 106K cr. matures this year, and will have to be paid out. According to the budget speech, we expect an ADDITIONAL net borrowing of 345,010 cr. this year, for the deficit of about 381,000 cr. Add that to the 106,000 cr. maturing, and we end up with a financing requirement of 451,000 cr. 

You might think: Hey – we are borrowing 106,000 cr. to pay back people we had borrowed from earlier? Isn’t that ponzi? Welcome to the world of government financing. And indeed most capital market finance.

Our GDP was 61,64,178 cr. in 2010, and we expect it to grow to around 69,30,000 cr. in 2010-11. That’s an additional 800,000 cr. in GDP that the entire country will do; while there’s no sense comparing incremental government debt to GDP growth figures, it gives you an idea of the scale of government borrowing.

(Note that this looks very good when applied, for instance, to western countries. The US will probably need to borrow $2 trillion. If they do REALLY well, they will grow about GDP by $700 billion.)

Also we’re slightly better off than countries abroad in terms of debt to GDP, but our interest payments are WAY too high. (20% of revenues is not a good thing – the US is at 5-7% and they are getting worried)

So what is the effective interest rate we pay? Overall, our payout is at 8% (considering all maturities). On a maturity year basis:

image

The most expensive debt is maturing in the next two years – at around 9.75%. If we are able to roll this over to say 8% yields, we’ll save about 3,500 cr. in interest on the same amounts. Look then at the distribution (the ultra low figures are floating rate bonds)

image

The size of the bubbles is the amount of debt outstanding. We have a small amount of leftover debt from really long back, at high rates; ignore those. But above 10% you notice a few large bubbles maturing in the next four-five years – those hurt us the most, and we need to roll them over at lower rates. But since the RBI is on an interest rate RAISING cycle, and inflation is already at 10%, it’s going to be a tug of war between RBI’s raising rates and the government balking from paying higher interest when rolling loans over.

A significant chunk of borrowing matures in the 2015-20 timeframe, and I’d imagine we have two choices – either have high inflation and thus devalue this debt to the point where it’s easy to pay back (remember, all this debt is in rupees) or scale to a current account surplus so we don’t need to refinance most of it.

The next year will be tough for the RBI – for controlling inflation and placing government bonds. In an environment where private players are willing to pay more and are now strong, government debt placement will be even more difficult, unless we let foreigners hold our debt. But if we do, that screws up the rupee-dollar equation; like I said, tough year for the RBI. A crisis of any sort, and we have to get back to the drawing table. (If we ever left it)

I presume this will be an ongoing task to keep the outstanding debt profile mapped. I’ll try and make a post every month, keeping a tab of all new issuances, maturities and buy backs.

Another Gilt Auction devolves

No Comments » Written on August 21st, 2009 by
Categories: Gilts
RBI's 12,000 cr. auction today was undersubscribed - meaning, not enough buyers - to extent of 912 cr., or 7.6% of the auction amount.

This devolves on the primary dealers - who will need to pay up. Funny thing is - the 7 6 year bond, a 2015 gilt, wasn't subscribed (short 591 cr.) even with a cut off yield at 7.10%. Just a few weeks back, bidders got in with a 10 year bond at 6.90% yield. (Which, btw, was also 321 cr. short of subscription, at a 7.30% yield) A few weeks, and the appetite for government bonds has degraded dramatically.

Some say it's because corporate credit is reviving, so people would rather lend to corporates at a higher yield. Of course, when as a government you swear to rescue anyone and everyone, obviously money will run to the higher interest rate - after all, if safety exists everywhere, why lend to the government. The moral hazard hits back.

But that may not quite be true. Banks dropped 130,000 cr. into reverse repo - meaning they really have no other use for the money.

Another common grouse was that RBI always sold illiquid bonds. But the benchmark 2019 bond is one of the most heavily traded; even that was undersubscribed.

It's not even like people are ditching bonds like mad. Just yesterday, the RBI tried to buy back bonds - last year's benchmark 10 year, the 2018 bond - at a yield of 7.28%. See, that's a couple basis points off the yield as RBI sold today - very well worth the effort of a year's wait less - and definitely in the "yield curve". Yet, the RBI couldn't buy enough at that yield - the buy-back only got them bonds worth 5,411 cr.

So it's not panic, yet yields are dropping like crazy; just the last few days have seen benchmark yields move from 7.01% to 7.30% - a fairly large move for an otherwise non-volatile bond. Bloomberg says there's no appetite for govt. bonds anymore. But someone forgot to tell the RBI; it's selling another 12,000 cr. next friday.

Being the regulator and watching so much money flowing into rev. repo every day, the RBI could hike the Statutory Liquidity Ratio (SLR) back to 25% (it had reduced SLR to 24% earlier, to help a bad liquidity situation). This extra 1% is about 28,000 cr. that the banks will need to buy SLR securities, government bonds being the most liquid of that variety.

The government's panic pushing of these bonds could be a sign of things to come; things you and I don't know about. Conspiracy theories abound - inflation will rise, so will interest rates, and the government will have to pay more. Or, a big bank or FI will go under, liquidity will drop and there won't be money to chase those bonds. Or, they need the money before swine flu goes berserk and they're afraid to touch your money then, so give it to them now please. Conspiracy theories are only fun if you have illegal substances to go with them.

Gilt Fund – Getting out half – yield at 7.18%

5 comments Written on August 20th, 2009 by
Categories: Gilts
I've been holding on to the gilt fund for a while and I'm sick of it - the yields are going up and prices are falling. At 7.18% it's the lowest I've seen for a while, and I am getting out of half my position. Why am I leaving half in there? Just a feeling there's going to be a better time in the next week.

I've made a miserable 4% gain in about 9 months - nothing to write home about. Luckily I won't pay any taxes on it - all of the money has come in as dividend.

Last week, the auction of 12,000 cr. devolved on primary dealers - meaning, not all of it was subscribed. 285 cr. of a 7 year bond and 630 cr. of a 11 year bond didn't get subscribed. A lot of bond sales have happened by the RBI lately, like most other governments, and the spirit is to sell even more while the going is good. Well, the going doesn't seem to be as good anymore.

What will be interesting is the impact of a bad monsoon on yields - with even lower revenues from the after effects of a bad monsoon, the deficit balloons further. At some point we will need to monetize it - meaning, the RBI will buy bonds directly (or, like in the US, slightly indirectly). Monetization breeds inflation - a fear that is currently not on the radar.

Still, this is all the expected result - nearly everyone in the market thinks of the deficit monetization as a conclusion. Yet, I've seen markets behave in really odd ways - will there be something different this time? Time will tell.

But I'm getting out when I still have a profit; hopefully it won't make me regret it by turning around right now!

RBI rejects government bond auction bids

6 comments Written on March 13th, 2009 by
Categories: Gilts
From ET:
The Reserve Bank of India has rejected all the bids received in the auctions held today for the sale of "7.46 per cent Government Stock 2017", "8.35 per cent Government Stock 2022" and "7.50 per cent Government Stock 2034".

It plans to announce in due course the revised date of the auction, the details of the securities, the method of auction, the central bank said in a press release. Meanwhile bond yields have fallen dramatically, with the new benchmark quoting at 6.61% after risng above 7% in the course of the day.

"Traders were hoping to sell their bonds to the central bank in OMO and then ask for a higher yield in the auction. RBI has caught them short by rejecting all bids. Naturally yields have collapsed," said a dealer at ICICI Securities.

Woohoo! What a wild time.

I don't believe these dealers one little bit. My strong belief is that they decided to hike yields up so they can get bonds cheap - after all, it's a small market, with a few primary dealers, and FIIs won't screw around ($200m cap per FII, only so many care). So if they pushed the market down, as has been happening over the last few days, they could easily get the bonds at far lower prices. They even short sold the bonds so they could buy back in the auction. (You can short sell bonds by borrowing them).

And when RBI rejected all bids, the rush to cover the short sales has driven yields up from 7.27% (2018) to 6.8% at close. (that's a price move of some 3%).

It's now entirely likely G-Secs will be sold later, or RBI will be much more active in the bond market. With deflation likely in two weeks, printing money isn't a bad alternative, to pay those that RBI buys bonds from. But if RBI chooses not to, gilts are going much lower.

Gilt yields go to 6.48%, a new low [on Price]

3 comments Written on February 17th, 2009 by
Categories: Gilts
The 10 year, 2018 bond ended at a yield of 6.48%, which is a new recent low in the price (111.6).

Reasons, they say, is that the government needs to borrow a lot, and the markets will be flooded. But put one more crisis - one bank, one real estate player, or an international credit situation - and people will rush to buy government bonds, regardless of any of these excuses. Yet, prices are going down daily, and it's a cause for worry.

Inflation at 4.39% is much lower and controlled - and if we go this way we're hitting deflation in the second week of April. Rate cuts are very likely, and quite interestingly, if we deflate, the government needn't borrow; it can simply print the money regardless. The deficit is about 45K cr. - which is nothing by most standards.

The fear is that rating agencies will de-rate India - but let me ask you this: Who the F cares about the rating agencies anymore? They were incompetent about Enron, they were incompetent with Lehman, and the fact the Indian government PRINTS our currency should give any Rupee Bond issues a AAA+++ rating, but they won't do it because they're so darn stupid (and of course, biased). At this point we're not even asking for foreign money (and it seems like should we ask, they're all lined up - right now they have a CAP on g-sec investments).

[Note: This might sound like a justification since I own gilt funds. And I'm wondering if it is too - but I'm convinced that within a year, we see 4% yields]

Gilt yields jump up suddenly, to 5.75%

9 comments Written on January 7th, 2009 by
Categories: Gilts
Gilt yields have gone berserk - up to 5.75% today. ET says its because the government is borrowing 50,000 cr..

But come on. 50,000 cr. is 1.25% of GDP. This is not a reason for bonds to lose nearly 4 rupees - or 3% - of their price. There has to be some other explanation, my idea being profit booking in general.

Let's see - prices come first, reasons come later. I still see rates at 4% later this year, so I'm holding.